When is a Ponzi scheme truly a Ponzi scheme?

HyperVerse operators, accused of a $1.8 billion Ponzi scheme, were indicted by U.S. officials. It appears that many crypto projects walk a thin line between a fraudulent investment scheme and legitimate ventures.

The Nature of Ponzi Schemes and Their Connection to Blockchain Protocols 🎪💸

Note: This is an enhanced rewrite of an article from The Node newsletter. For the full newsletter, subscribe here.

Have you ever wondered if there are elements of Ponzi schemes in the world of finance, including the ever-popular crypto market? Well, let’s dive into the fascinating world of “ponzinomics” and explore the connection between Ponzi-like incentives and blockchain protocols.

What Is Ponzinomics? 🔄

While the term “ponzinomics” might not be recognized in the dictionary, its meaning is intuitive. We can identify a project as being “Ponzi-like” when it encourages adoption by making implicit or explicit promises of wealth, whether fraudulent or not. This concept is derived from the infamous investment fraud named after Charles Ponzi, who attracted investors with the allure of high returns while using new investments to pay off existing ones.

To shed more light on this subject, let’s take a step back and look into the world of multi-level marketing schemes. In his book “Ponzinomics: The Untold Story of Multi-Level Marketing,” Robert FitzPatrick argues that pyramid-like financial structures can be found in companies like Nutrilite and Amway, where money primarily flows to the top through deceptive recruitment techniques. These companies present themselves as legitimate businesses selling products or services, but the primary source of income is recruitment.

• Shift in Illicit Crypto Activity: Beyond Bitcoin
• 💼 Introducing Billy Mullins: MatterFi’s New CTO
• 🚀 Spot Bitcoin ETFs: A Roller Coaster Ride for Bitcoin, But Don’t Give Up Hope! 🎢💰

Ponzinomics in Various Spheres 💼

Interestingly, ponzinomic incentives are not limited to the world of multi-level marketing schemes. The renowned economist Hyman Minsky introduced the term “ponzi finance,” which characterizes zombie corporations that continue to meet their debt commitments by continuously acquiring new funding, despite being functionally dead. Furthermore, economists have theorized that national debts can become “Ponzi games” if governments continually repay existing debt by issuing new bonds.

This leads us to the question: when does ponzinomics cross the line and become genuinely fraudulent? Regulators often label crypto scams as Ponzi schemes, as seen in the recent indictment of HyperVerse by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). In this case, Australian “blockchain entrepreneur” Sam Lee allegedly defrauded investors of a staggering $1.89 billion.

The Bizarre Case of HyperVerse 🎢

The HyperVerse story has captured mainstream attention due to its jaw-dropping figures and peculiar circumstances. It turns out that Lee and his co-conspirators, including Brenda Chunga, paid an actor to impersonate a CEO and secured endorsements from celebrities like Chuck Norris and Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak. How’s that for a wild ride?

According to court documents, HyperVerse operated as a “pyramid and Ponzi scheme,” enticing investors with promises of high returns from crypto mining and other false claims, including the creation of a metaverse. However, as SEC Enforcement Director Gurbir S. Grewal rightly stated, “The only thing that HyperFund mined was its investors’ pockets.”

Surprisingly, when we consider how Lee and Chunga allegedly spent the money, it becomes apparent that the scheme itself wasn’t very profitable. Sure, they indulged in luxury purchases like cars, properties, and designer clothing, but given the massive amount of money raised, it seems the HyperVerse Ponzi survived for so long because it used incoming revenue to pay out existing users.

The MLM Component 👥

HyperVerse also incorporated a multi-level marketing (MLM) component, making it all the more intriguing. Chunga, one of the few “corporate” presenters, received over $3.7 million from the platform, both through the HyperFund system and by personally recruiting investors in the U.S. This highlights the recurring theme of deceptive recruitment techniques that funnel money to the top in pyramid-like structures.

Unfortunately for HyperVerse’s promoters, the scheme eventually unraveled when withdrawals were frozen in 2022. Towards the end, they tried to squeeze even more money out of investors by selling $10,000 NFTs and promising a “university-level blockchain education.” But as we know, Ponzi schemes can only last as long as there are people left to deceive. In this regard, some crypto projects might share a striking resemblance to Ponzi schemes too.

The Verdict and Beyond ⚖️

Ponzinomics poses an intriguing question: what distinguishes it from legitimate practices? While the crypto market is often associated with scams and fraudulent schemes, not all projects with Ponzi-like incentives are necessarily fraudulent. If the capital is put to productive use, it can have positive outcomes. However, there’s no denying that it increases the risk for later adopters, potentially leading to a collapse unless the system is made sustainable.

When it comes to crypto scams like HyperVerse, the authorities play a crucial role in identifying and prosecuting fraudulent activities. In this case, the involvement of regulators and the staggering amount of money involved have grabbed headlines.

🤔 Q&A Time: Questions and Concerns Related to Ponzinomics and Crypto Scams

Q: How can I identify a potentially fraudulent crypto project? A: Look for explicit or implicit promises of exorbitant returns, lack of transparency or verifiable information, and a heavy emphasis on recruitment rather than a viable product or service.

Q: Can you recommend any resources to stay informed about the latest crypto scams? A: Absolutely! Here are some links to websites and articles that regularly provide updates and insights on crypto scams and fraudulent activities: Link 1, Link 2.

Q: Is there any hope for people who fall victim to crypto scams? A: While it’s tough to recover funds lost to scams, it’s important to report the incident to the relevant authorities, maintain documentation, and seek legal advice. In some cases, there might be a chance of restitution, especially if the authorities successfully apprehend the perpetrators.

Q: What steps can regulators and authorities take to combat crypto scams effectively? A: Regulators need to stay vigilant and responsive to emerging trends and scams in the crypto market. Collaborating with international counterparts, implementing stricter regulations, and conducting thorough investigations are crucial steps in protecting investors and maintaining market integrity.

Moving forward, it’s essential for both regulators and investors to stay informed and vigilant to mitigate the risks associated with ponzinomics and crypto scams. By promoting transparency, responsible investment practices, and regulatory oversight, we can foster a more secure and sustainable crypto ecosystem.

📚 Reference List: Relevant Links

1. Title: US Recession 2024 becomes hot debate among economists sharing mixed views

2. Title: This Is How Scammers Can Drain Your Crypto Wallet

3. Title: 6 Kinds of Crypto Scams and How to Avoid Them

As always, we’d love to hear your thoughts! Let us know in the comments below and don’t forget to share this article on your favorite social media platforms. Together, we can navigate the complex world of crypto with humor and knowledge! 🚀🌐✨

We will continue to update Blocking; if you have any questions or suggestions, please contact us!