S&P Global Gets “Picky” with Stablecoins: Tether Slapped with Meh Score

Tether Ranks Second-to-Last in S&P Global's Assessment of Stablecoin Stability

Tether ranks second-lowest in S&P Global Stablecoin Stability Assessment

In a move that has stirred quite the debate, ratings company S&P Global recently introduced a quirky “stablecoin stability assessment.” While some may envision a rodeo of digital assets desperately clinging to their precious pegs, the reality is slightly less exhilarating. S&P Global assigned scores from 1 (meaning “very strong”) to 5 (as weak as the boss’ coffee) to discern just how well these cryptocurrencies can hold their fiat-currency pegs.

So, how did the stablecoins fare in this cryptic test of mettle? Well, buckle up! None managed to snag the illustrious 1 score. Instead, the podium featured three familiar faces – Gemini dollar (GUSD), USD Coin (USDC), and Pax Dollar (USDP) – making up a respectable top three with scores of 2. But it was the behemoth Tether (USDT) that received the underwhelming score of 4 (cue disappointed applause). Perhaps “constraint” isn’t the most exciting superpower for a stablecoin after all. And let’s not forget about the real losers of the assessment: TrueUSD (TUSD) and Frax (FRAX), awarded with the lowest rank. Ouch!

Now, for those uninitiated into the mystical world of stablecoins, let’s unravel their enigmatic essence. These cheeky digital assets often hug real-world assets like the trusty U.S. dollar, aiming to keep their value locked down tight. However, a few rebels dare to dream differently, relying on mathematical algorithms to maintain their worth. S&P’s assessment delved deep into the risk quagmire, examining factors like credit risks, market value volatility, custody risks, liquidation parties (not the fun kind), and overcollateralization. It’s like watching a circus high-wire act, except instead of clowns, we have algorithms, and instead of a safety net, we have a flurry of dollar signs.

Lapo Guadagnuolo, a senior analyst at S&P Global Ratings, gazed into the crystal ball of stablecoin future. “As we look to the future, we see stablecoins becoming further embedded into the fabric of financial markets, acting as an important bridge between digital and real-world assets,” he predicted. Alas, even in these celebratory moments, he couldn’t help but remind us that stablecoins aren’t immune to pesky factors like asset quality, governance (yawn), and liquidity (double yawn). Sigh, when will the stablecoin superheroes get a break?

• Dubai Regulator Elevates Crypto Game Bahrain’s CoinMENA Granted License
• Su Zhu, the “Jailbird” Co-founder of Three Arrows Capital
• Three Arrows Co-Founder Su Zhu Faces Singapore Court Showdown in Thrilling Asset Hunt Bloomberg

Now, let’s turn our attention to the elephant in the crypto room (it’s not Elon Musk in a bear suit, we promise). Tether (USDT), the third-biggest crypto after the reigning champs Bitcoin (BTC) and Ethereum (ETH), has a market capitalization that would make Scrooge McDuck blush – over $90 billion! So, what’s the beef with Tether? Last November, when concerns swirled around crypto exchange FTX, Tether bravely dropped 3% below its peg. It blamed “market volatility,” as if the markets were having an impromptu dance-off. But hey, even superheroes need a break every now and then, right?

Not everyone seems thrilled by the fascinating world of stablecoins. The Bank for International Settlements (BIS), the gathering of central bank overlords, cast a skeptical gaze upon the stability of these digital wonders. Much like a magician revealing the trick behind a card trick, the BIS expressed concerns about “transparency regarding the availability and quality of these reserves.” S&P concurred, stating that participants in decentralized finance (DeFi) and traditional finance (TradFi) wander aimlessly in a sea devoid of transparency or insight into the inherent risks of different stablecoins. Cue the mysterious fog and ominous music, because this sounds like a job for Inspector Transparency!

So, what’s our takeaway from this wild adventure into stablecoin land? Well, fellow investors, it’s time to strap on your metaphorical seatbelts and ride this crypto wave with caution and a dash of skepticism. Will stablecoins rise victorious, bridging the ever-widening gap between digital and real-world assets? Only time will tell. But hey, at least we now know how “stable” these coins are, or aren’t, according to ratings companies like S&P Global. And isn’t knowledge the most valuable currency of all?

Phew! We’ve journeyed through the intriguing domain of stablecoins, faced the ghosts of market volatility, and emerged with a newfound appreciation for transparency. But what do you think, my fellow digital asset adventurers? Are stablecoins the heroes we need, or are they destined to remain the sidekicks? Share your thoughts and let’s continue this epic quest for financial enlightenment together!

We will continue to update Blocking; if you have any questions or suggestions, please contact us!