Clearview AI’s Surprise Victory UK Court Overturns GDPR Challenge on Surveillance and Facial Recognition

Clearview AI Prevails in UK Court GDPR Appeal for US Surveillance and Facial Recognition

U.S. surveillance and facial recognition firm Clearview AI recently had a court victory in the United Kingdom, and boy oh boy, it’s got everyone talking! You see, they were accused of breaching the U.K.’s general data protection regulation (GDPR), and faced a hefty fine of nearly $10 million. But Clearview AI won the appeal, and now that fine might just be history, unless the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) decides to shake things up with another appeal.

According to Tribunal Judge Lynn Griffin, whether Clearview AI violated the GDPR or not is not the main issue here. The real deal is whether the GDPR even applies to foreign companies like Clearview AI. It’s all about jurisdiction, my friends. As the court documents released on October 17th state, “Whether or not CV has infringed the Articles of GDPR or UK GDPR as alleged or at all was not the issue before us. That would be the subject of any substantive hearing were this case to go forward.”

So, in plain English, despite Clearview AI having billions of images in its facial recognition and surveillance system (which, experts say, include images from the U.K. sourced from “public” internet repositories), the U.K.’s ICO simply doesn’t have the power to enforce GDPR protection in this case.

The court document goes on to say that since Clearview AI is a foreign company serving foreign clients, using foreign IP addresses, all in support of national security and criminal law enforcement purposes, the U.K.’s GDPR jurisdiction doesn’t extend to them. It’s like trying to regulate a wild stallion that has galloped far away from the barn.

This precedent-setting victory of Clearview AI is quite the game-changer. It pretty much restricts the enforcement of GDPR to companies solely within the U.K.’s jurisdiction. But hold on, folks, because the plot thickens! Clearview AI has actually faced multiple lawsuits and fines in Europe, thanks to the EU’s GDPR. France, Italy, and Greece have all put a price tag on Clearview AI’s shenanigans. Even Sweden’s local police authority was fined over $300K for using Clearview AI’s products illegally in 2021. They clearly need some serious facial recognition of their own to wipe that smug grin off their faces.

But wait, there’s more! Clearview AI seems to have some magic tricks up its sleeve. Even though they were slapped with a massive $20 million fine in France for breaching the GDPR in October 2022, they simply refused to pay up. And guess what? In May 2023, they were found in breach of that order. It’s like trying to teach a bullfrog to sing opera. They just won’t follow the rules, will they?

Here’s where it gets even spicier. Clearview AI, with its controversial software and services, has managed to walk on a tightrope between civil rights and privacy protections. Some experts claim they’ve been floating above the law, despite the fact that their close ties with law enforcement should have made them bound by the same principles as the rest. It’s like being a unicorn in a paddock of horses. They’re special, apparently.

And that’s not all, my friends. If you think you can escape from Clearview AI’s clutches, think again. It’s nearly impossible to remove your data from their databases and systems. They’ve got their hooks in so deep that most people can’t even dream of getting out. According to Clearview AI’s Privacy Policy, only residents of certain states have a chance to submit a request to access, opt-out, or delete their information. It’s like being stuck in a twisted version of a state fair, where only folks from California, Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois, and Virginia get a shot at the ride.

If you’re one of those unlucky souls living outside those privileged states, well, tough luck! Clearview AI has made it clear that they may have sold your precious face vectors and photographs to law enforcement, government agencies, and other bigwigs in the security business. You’ve been caught in their web, my friend, and it’s not easy to break free.

So, if you’re feeling like you’re swimming in a sea of Clearview AI’s data, remember this: you’re not alone. There are others out there, struggling to reclaim their privacy and protect their rights. Keep fighting, keep pushing, and who knows, maybe one day we’ll all be free from the clutches of this digital behemoth.

But for now, stay strong, stay informed, and keep on investing in the future. After all, the world of digital assets is as exciting and unpredictable as a roller coaster ride. So buckle up and enjoy the wild journey!

Have you had any encounters with Clearview AI or similar digital monsters? Share your stories and let’s commiserate together in the comments below!

We will continue to update Blocking; if you have any questions or suggestions, please contact us!

Share:

Was this article helpful?

93 out of 132 found this helpful

Discover more

Policy

A Review of Hong Kong's Cryptocurrency Regulatory Policy Process Hong Kong has become another treasure trove in the encrypted world

On the one-year anniversary of the launch of virtual assets in Hong Kong, what major policies are being implemented t...

Market

Hong Kong has too many smart people, there are no more "leeks" in the currency circle.

Hong Kong, the cryptocurrency market, and the abundance of smart people - "Chives" no longer exist in the cryptocurre...

Bitcoin

SEC Caught in a Race Against the Clock to Appeal Court Ruling on Grayscale Bitcoin ETF

Fashionistas Take Note SEC's Deadline Looms for Bitcoin ETF Appeal - What Comes Next?

Blockchain

Where is Hong Kong's OTC regulation heading?

Regulations are imminent, OTC stores are operating normally, industry experts say that regulators need to find a bala...

Finance

Hong Kong's new encryption regulations come into effect: taking stock of the "first batch of pioneers"

Web3 has attracted the attention of integrated institutions, exchanges, project parties, and even traditional financi...

Blockchain

Hong Kong Monetary Authority: Eight virtual banking licenses have been issued, Hong Kong's first virtual bank is expected to open for trial by the end of the year

Author: Reporter Luo Shu Yi in Beijing Source: Economic Reference Recently, Yu Weiwen, the new president of the Hong ...