Forbes: Will the US Internal Revenue Service kill cryptocurrency transactions?

On Monday, the commercial media Forbes wrote an analysis of how the US Internal Revenue Service (IRS) encryption policy affects the world of cryptocurrencies.

According to the article, the IRS announced in 2014 that the cryptocurrency is an asset, and after five years, it said that the cryptocurrency from the hard fork needs to pay taxes. There is currently no official tax guide for cryptocurrency transactions. As we all know, tax law 1031 is currently only applicable to real estate. For the situation before 2017, Suzanne Sinno, an attorney at the IRS Consultancy Office, said that Section 1031 of the Tax Code does not apply to cryptocurrencies.

Sinno is involved in the preparation of the new cryptocurrency guide recently released by IRS, but this is not an official statement, nor is it an "authoritative" interpretation of federal income tax purposes. Another IRS official recently withdrew his previous comments, which said it depends on the circumstances.

The IRS does not have a total denial of the tax law 1031 applicable to cryptocurrency, which may mean that the IRS may postpone the review, especially considering the huge differences in how taxpayers treat and report their cryptocurrency transactions.

Article 1031 of the Tax Law stipulates that transactions used for trading or holding similar assets for investment purposes do not generate profit or loss. However, it does not apply to “stocks, bonds, notes or other securities, debt or interest certificates.” This means determining whether the two types of assets are “like”. The IRS sometimes uses narrow interpretations when analyzing transactions in physical assets. For example, in the tax ruling of No.79-143, the IRS ruled that coins and gold and silver coins are not “similar” property, because in addition to gold, coins can be valued according to the year and the product, while gold and silver coins are valued according to the price of gold.

Similarly, gold bars and bars used for investment are not “like” assets because gold and silver are different metals and are used in different ways (gold for investment and silver for industrial goods). Therefore, IRS may think that, like gold bars and silver bars, cryptocurrencies are subject to different market forces and use different investments in different ways.

However, the IRS announced in 2014 that all digital currencies are assets, which seems to indicate that they are similar in nature. Previously, the IRS had concluded that taxpayers had replaced FCC radio licenses with FCC television licenses as “similar assets” transactions as described in Tax Law 1031. For different cryptocurrencies, it can be said that there are more similarities than the difference.

However, there is another issue in this issue. The IRS may consider the cryptocurrency to be a "securities" and not eligible for "like transactions." Because cryptocurrencies can be traded on exchanges like stocks and bonds.

In the 1960s and 1970s, the IRS made a preliminary decision on whether the Whiskey Warehouse Receipt (WWR) should be considered as the securities mentioned in Section 1031 of the Tax Code. WWR represents the inventory of whiskey, which is considered by the Securities and Exchange Commission to be a security, but IRS does not consider WWR as the security mentioned in Section 1031 of the Tax Code.

Even so, the final issue may still need to be resolved in court. The IRS Appeals Office is where many tax disputes are finally settled. The IRS order is not absolute and will ultimately be decided by the court.

Image source: pixabay

By Xiu MU

This article comes from the push, reproduced need to indicate the source.

We will continue to update Blocking; if you have any questions or suggestions, please contact us!


Was this article helpful?

93 out of 132 found this helpful

Discover more


BlackRock’s Bitcoin ETF: Banks Welcomed with Open Arms

BlackRock's updated Bitcoin ETF proposal now allows banks to participate through broker-dealers, providing wider mark...


🏎️ Enhancing the Excitement: Wingalaxy Revs Up the Racing Game on the Cronos Blockchain 🏁

Wingalaxy has recently announced the launch of their first race-to-win game on the Cronos blockchain, specifically de...


The Jovial Journey of Starknet: Join the Early Community Member Program and Reap the Rewards!

Great news for fashion enthusiasts! The Starknet Foundation is giving away 50 million STRK tokens in its Early Commun...


Ethereum ETF Approval Anticipation Fuels ETH’s Latest Price Rally 📈🚀

The value of Ethereum has seen a remarkable increase, surpassing the $2800 milestone and currently showing potential ...


JPMorgan CEO Threatens Crypto: A Criminal’s Best Friend or Innovation’s Gateway?

In a recent statement, Dimon expressed his belief that cryptocurrency companies should undergo the same AML regulatio...


🐻 Berachain: The Bear-themed Blockchain Project Reaches Unicorn Status with New Funding

Berachain has successfully secured funding after a successful fundraising campaign in April 2023. The company was abl...