Should blockchain transactions be rolled back? Vitalik's small investigation sparked a big discussion

Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin sparked controversy in the cryptocurrency community after proposing developers to reverse transactions.

Etherum

In a Twitter survey yesterday, Buterin asked the user's perception of the rollback blockchain activity when a major hacker attack on an exchange or similar entity.

“Assuming there is a very popular smart contract wallet, most people in the Ethereum community are using it, but this contract has been hacked. We can do a DAO-like operation by reversing all chain activities after the hacker attack. Hard fork to get back all the money."

1

Then, he also asked how many coins were stolen and the community would support manual rollback transactions.

The survey seems to have touched the nerves of some people. They believe that morally, this has nothing to do with the amount of money – the act of rolling back the transaction will lead to the centralization of the blockchain.

Someone even said mercilessly:

“Ultimately, it all depends on whether Vitalik is a user of a wallet.”

"This blockchain is the Failchain (failed chain)," concludes Bitcoin expert Dennis Parker.

It has also been suggested that if a smart contract is attacked, the creator should compensate the user because the fundamental problem is its design, not the entire blockchain network.

However, more than 60% of the more than 10,000 voting users confirmed that they would not tolerate any remedy under any circumstances.

Ethereum developers have carried out transaction rollbacks. In June 2016, after the decentralized autonomous organization DAO was hacked, developers chose hard forks to roll back transactions. That attack caused the loss of Ethereum, which was worth $60 million at the time.

Ethereum is currently undergoing a long-term upgrade that will eventually change its algorithm. These improvements will help solve the "growth troubles" that the network faces – in August, Buterin said that the Ethereum blockchain is almost full.

Despite this, as the largest competitive currency in the market, Ethereum has performed modestly this year, while Bitcoin has firmly occupied the top position.

We will continue to update Blocking; if you have any questions or suggestions, please contact us!

Share:

Was this article helpful?

93 out of 132 found this helpful

Discover more

Blockchain

The kimchi premium breaks $1,000! South Korea’s "disfigured alcohol addiction" has another episode?

The quiet year's kimchi premium once again swayed, and it was a bit like the scene before the bull market in 201...

Blockchain

Hong Kong's anti-acquisition new deal will take effect, and the "coin stock" of the fire currency will be renamed as a risk

Tongcheng Holdings Co., Ltd. (HK1611) issued an announcement proposing to change the company name to Firecoin Technol...

Blockchain

Italian securities regulator establishes cryptocurrency regulations, has closed 2 cryptocurrency trading sites

Cointelegraph reported on February 11 that Italian securities regulators recently closed six foreign exchange trading...

Market

The ultimate way out of cryptocurrency exchanges: decentralization (below)

The full text is brief: Alicoin|Exclusive view With the endless stream of asset security cases such as hacking and se...

Blockchain

The money was not earned, and the head was almost bald: interview with the boss of the startup exchange

Currently, one of the most profitable industries in the cryptocurrency sector is the exchange. According to The Block...

Blockchain

Yesterday, 340,000 ETH on the Upbit exchange was stolen, but this server was attacked ...

Author: Chengdu chain security According to industry media reports, around 1 pm on November 27, the security system o...